Match Report Tuesday 10th November 2015

IMG_2879With Remembrance day in mind the P/M kicked the evening off, breaking in his new Red Welt bag, with The Battle of the Somme.IMG_2877

‘Fought between July 1 and November 1, 1918 near the Somme River in France, it was also one of the bloodiest military battles in history. On the first day alone, the British suffered more than 57,000 casualties, and by the end of the campaign the Allies and Central Powers would lose more than 1.5 million men.’

Iain Kirkwood was up next and after a few warm up tunes gave us the ground and first couple of variations of His Fathers Lament for Donald MacKenzie.IMG_2861

A quartet from Fettes College, under the wing of Cameron Drummond, then took to the floor. Seamus O’Baoighill, Torquil LeRoy-Lewis, David Maitland-Biddulph and Harry Campbell of Losrosque (ok Harrys not from Lochrosque but it just goes better with the groups names) were in great form. Having a quick run out before the schools competition this coming Friday, they settled the pipes down before playing their IMG_2863competition medley. Great stuff boys and best of luck.

The pre pie piper was Nils Michael. Nils was in a relaxed mood and his pipe was rich and well balanced. He played an excellent selection of light music that included the 2/4 Marches, Tommy MacDonald of Barguillean and Douglas Gardiner, both IMG_2870composed by Dr Bruce Thomson. The amusing anecdote is that while Nils was playing the second tune, Douglas Gardiner, there were the usual glances around the room to see if anyone recognised it. Shakes of the head all round, including Douglas Gardiner himself. When Nils finished and announced the title, Douglas asked where he got the music. ‘You sent it to me’, was the reply. So so funny. ‘It’s been a while since I’ve heard it, said DG.’


Dr Bruce Thomson


Douglas Gardiner by Dr Bruce Thomson

As the pies were being served the P/M made mention of the notable prizes won at London by Eagles members, not least Cameron Drummond who dam near won the overall champion piper. His hornpipe and jig, The Stornoway Hornpipe and The Handshaker was out of this world.

Bratach Gorm

1st Roddy MacLeod, “A Son’s Salute to his Parents”

2nd Gordon Walker, Moscow, Scotland

3rd Callum Beaumont, Bo’ness, Scotland

4th Willie McCallum, Bearsden, Scotland

Also competing: Glenn Brown, John-Angus Smith

Judges: Neill Mulvie, Jack Taylor, Bill Wotherspoon

Open Piobaireachd (William Gillies Memorial)

1st Chris Armstrong

2nd Roddy MacLeod

3rd Cameron Drummond, Edinburgh

4th Willie McCallum

5th Jamie Forrester, London

Judges: Roddy Livingstone, John Wilson, Andrew Wright

Premier and A-Grade
MSR (London Medallion / John MacFadyen Quaich)

1st Callum Beaumont

2nd Willie McCallum

3rd Cameron Drummond

4th Roddy MacLeod

5th Glenn Brown, Glasgow

Judges: Jimmy Banks, Walter Cowan, Bob Worrall

March (J.B. Robertson Rose Bowl)

1st Alasdair Henderson, Dunoon, Scotland

2nd Gordon Walker

3rd Callum Beaumont

4th Cameron Drummond

5th Chris Armstrong

Judges: Euan Anderson, Andrew Frater, Iain MacLellan

Hornpipe & Jig (Mary Flora Beaton Cup)

1st Cameron Drummond

2nd Alasdair Henderson

3rd Callum Beaumont

Judges: Euan Anderson, Andrew Frater, Iain MacLellan


Piobaireachd (Snuff Mull)

1st Cameron Drummond

2nd Alasdair Henderson

3rd Derek Midgley, New Jersey

4th Innes Smith

5th Peter McGregor

Judges: Tom Johnstone, Ronnie McShannon

MSR (Strachan Cup)

1st Steven Leask

2nd Jenny Hazzard, Edinburgh

3rd Ben McClamrock, Baltimore

4th Ross Miller

5th Ashley McMichael

Judges: Jimmy Banks, Walter Cowan, Bob Worrall

Hornpipe & Jig

1st Steven Leask

2nd Ross Miller

3rd Ashley McMichael

Judges: Euan Anderson, Andrew Frater, Iain MacLellan



1st Xavier Bouderiou, Brittany

2nd Greig Canning, Edinburgh

3rd Ben McClamrock

4th Nick Hudson, Pittsburgh

5th Ross Cowan, Annan, Scotland

Judges: Archie MacLean, Rab Wallace


1st Lachie Dick, Edinburgh

2nd Callum Moffatt

3rd Greig Canning

4th Andrew Hall

5th Graham Mulholland

Judges: Euan Anderson, Dixie Ingram, Colin MacLellan

Hornpipe & Jig

1st Calum Watson

2nd Callum Moffatt

3rd Andrew Wilson



1st Ross MacKay

2nd Graham Mulholland

3rd Jonathan Simpson

4th John Mackey

5th Callum Carswell


1st Alasdair Donaghue

2nd Eddie Gaul

3rd Ross MacKay

4th Katherine Belcher

5th Craig Holsquist

Hornpipe & Jig

1st Alasdair Donaghue

2nd Greg McAllister

3rd Andrew Bell


Katherine Belcher

The post pie piper was the wee spoon herself and she was quickly about her business with an eye on this weekends Capt. John MacLellan competition. On a lovely pipe she played 2x 2/4 marches Mrs Donald McLean and Arthur Bignold of Losrosque (Harry’s uncle?). This was followed by a spot of Ceol Mor that will stand her in good stead for the weekend, despite her 1st on draw.

Douglas Gardiner, (who has a 2/4 march named after him ya ken) was the final player of the night. Douglas is also having a run out at the weekend and he stepped his way through a variety of light music before giving is a lovely Battle of Auldearn No2. Great pipe and well executed.

Douglas Gardiner

Douglas Gardiner

‘The battle of Auldearn was fought during the civil wars of the mid seventeenth century in May 1645 between a Covenanting army and the royalists under the famous Marquis of Montrose.’

And that was the evenings evening.

Coming up, The Capt John MacLellan competition this Saturday at the Army School of Piping KO 09.00hrs.

The Scots Guard’s KO competition rounds have been published.IMG_2866

Fred Morrison is in Edinburgh on the 29th November.

See you the next Eagles meeting on Tuesday 24th NovemberIMG_2867

Euan Anderson

Hon P/M

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Match report Tuesday 27th October 2015

With the Glenfiddich behind us, (congratulations go to Angus McColl on his overall win), and the final big indoor contest looming in London this weekend, another piping year is coming to a close, but work has still to be done.

P1040372As we welcomed international piping impresario Bob Worrall to the fold, Kat Belcher got the show going. She was straight into the big stuff on a lovely steady instrument. After a couple of MSRs she treated us to the ground of the great Lament for the McSwan of Roaig. If she can take this quality down South she should do well.

The Wee Spoon

The Wee Spoon

It was nice to see Anne Vroomen from the Netherlands in the audience. Anne was also up at the Glenfiddich championships and was catching an Eagles night before heading home.


Anne and Scott Hannah

Next for shaving was Lachie Dick, who was on another good pipe, well balanced and pleasing to the ear. After a few warm up tunes he was straight into his London competition tunes before presenting a very musical MacCrimmon’s Sweetheart. The tune was technically sound and again this standard will hold up well in the competition arena.


Lachie Dick

Cameron Drummond was the post pie piper and he tuned up with first variation and doubling of The Unjust Incarceration. This was followed by a couple of jigs and 2 x 2/4 marches that included the little heard and technically challenging Glengarry Gathering. First class.


Cameron Drummond

Andrew Gray was next up, back on his old set of sticks that suited the solo performer. Again Andrew was quickly into his London tunes knocking off a double MSR. He concluded with a lively hornpipe and jig, The Ladies Hornpipe and Kenny Gillies of Portnalong.


Andrew Gray

Last to play was Jenny Hazzard, who had clearly survived the strip the willow challenges at the Atholl Palace (in high heels). Jenny followed suit by not wasting much time before heading into the big stuff. Once the pipe was settled she played The Lament for the Duke of Hamilton.

This tune may have been composed by Padruig Mor MacCrimmon in honour of William Hamilton, 2nd Duke of Hamilton. The Duke, age 35, was fatally wounded at the Battle of Worcester, 1651. Padruig Mor was himself at the battle, serving under Ruaridh MacLeod of Talisker and Norman MacLeod of Berneray, sons of the deceased Sir Ruaridh Mor, 15th Chieftain of Harris and Dunvegan MacLeods.


Composed by Patrick Mor MacCrimmon and James the 4th Duke of Hamilton was killed in a duel in Hyde Park by Lord Macartney 1712’………………


Jenny Hazzard

Whatever the tunes origins Jenny made a splendid job of it. Although a lament Jenny kept a nice tempo in the latter stages with a nice brisk fosgailte to finish.

What a lovely wee feast of Ceol Mor.

Good luck to all in London and hope to see you at the next meeting on Tuesday 10th November.

Euan Anderson

Hon P/M

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

What’s in a name? From Dunaber Music-We stand correct Sir.

major-manson-at-clachantrushal-231x300September 13, 2015 on 6:56 pm by Michael Grey | In News, Random Thoughts, Solo Piping, Whinges | No Comments
There are a couple of instances where people might talk and, so, where I find myself more riled up than other times: those that get me going more than almost any other: the first, the georgebushian “nucular”, for nuclear (as in war and bombs) and the second related to the pipe tune, “Pipe Major Manson’s Farewell to Clachantrushal” for “Major David Manson AT Clachantrushal”, the later being the accurate and right name for this bagpipe 2/4-timed march – played always and often in bagpipe circles.

Why the bother, you ask? And get a life – I hear you.

I think, first, if I was true to myself and fessing up, well, it’s a parochial [Great Highland] bagpipe thing: it’s just not permitted in our little world to have perceived errors in fact or musical score portrayed as otherwise in any situation – dammit. Along with that, this tune is played a lot, and in name, represented wrongly – a lot.

The second? As a guy who makes tunes from time to time it bugs me that people frequently screw with titles – tune titles. To pipers (and some publishers) tune titles mean little and, generally, and are forgotten often.

Not many tune titles happen by accident and all of them are there to represent something important to the composer, and, in turn, the star of the tune – be that a person, place or thing.

And so, did the melody in question – composed, in this example, by Donald MacLean (Lewis) stand as a “fond, emotional farewell” or a “geezuz, for gawd sakes, yer still here?” commemoration [yes, Donald MacLean of THAT 6/8-timed march by Donald MacLeod]?

Here’s the frontispiece for the small two-tune folder published by Glasgow’s College of Piping in the 1950s; just to keep us right.

Major David Manson at Clachantrushal

And a few words on the composer, Pipe Major Donald MacLean, courtesy of

“On June 12, 1940, he, along with the likes of Donald MacLeod, John Wilson, George McIntyre and many other pipers in the 51st Highland Division, were captured in France at St. Valery. He would spend the next five years as a prisoner of war in Germany and Poland. It was during this time that he wrote his famous competition march “Major David Manson at Clachantrushal” on a practice chanter borrowed from fellow piper Alex Craig. David Manson was a retired officer of the Canadian army who worked as a Glasgow silversmith. He had visited Donald’s home before the war and gave him a set of engraved silver pipes. “Clachantrushal” refers to a monolith – said to be the largest standing stone in Scotland – that stands near the home.”

Clachantrushal: A place, it seems, to be “at” and not “from”.

And get those tune titles right.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Match Report Tuesday 13th October 2015

IMG_2815On the eve of the auction of Donald MacPherson’s clasps and other notable awards, that included a couple of Eagle Pipers’ medals, it gave food for though with regards what value we put on major piping success. After all the prize money is generally no great shakes, so in the main we play for pleasure and the chance of playing ourselves into the history books-for those at the top end of the game that is.IMG_2814

So what price a clasp? To buy off the shelf surely no more than £100, tops? Times 8, £800, however when under the hammer £11 000 was not enough to secure the greatest ever prize winning pipers quarry, that had a reserve in place that was clearly not met. Mind you if you had 8 clasps in your family would you sell them? That aside what remains is the absolute fact that the man himself was one hell of a player.

IMG_2813The P/M got the evening under way with a couple of Donald’s tunes before moving onto some 3/4s and finishing with a couple of  Donald’s McLeod 6/8’s.


Scott Hannah

With the pipe nice and settled Scott Hannah, of Shotts and Dykehead fame, borrowed the P/Ms instrument and kicked off with, Shotts Farewell to Jim Kilpatrick. OK he didn’t actually play that, but if there had been such a tune it would have been more than appropriate, with Jim announcing that he is stepping down as leading tip.

What a drummer and what a record. One that will probably never be surpassed, 60 major drum corps titles, including 16 World Drum Corps Championships (a record 11 straight, 1988-’98) As leading-drummer the band won 31 major championships and six World titles not to mention his 16 solo world drumming titles. Wow.

Unknown-1Anyway Scott was quickly into his stride and rolled off three competition marches Major Manson Farewell to Clachantrushal, Mrs. John McColl and John MacColl’s March to Kilbowie Cottage. And with that he was done. A new bag awaits for his own pipe!


Iain Kirkwood

Next for shaving was Iain Kirkwood, who played a couple of tunes before giving us the Donald McLeod composition, Queen Elizabeth the Seconds Salute. Very nice.

The PPP was Nils M. who kicked off with an old favorite, Farewell to the Creeks, also known as The 51st Highland Division’s Farewell To Sicily composed by Pipe Major James Robertson of Boyne, Banffshire, in 1915, when he was a prisoner of war in Germany.

Nils was in fine form and played the lovely slow air Samantha’s Lullaby.IMG_2797

To finish off the evening Jenny Hazzard took to the floor and explained to the audience that she has a hard winter ahead of her. She is to take part in a reprise of the 78th Fraser Highlanders 1987 Live in Ireland Concert, that is taking place on the 30th January, 13.00hrs, Glasgow Royal Concert Hall, as part of Celtic Connections. Our own Michael Grey (yes ours, as once you launch a book at the Eagles you are part of the gang) is one of the driving forces behind it. Here’s what it says on the Celtic Connections website



‘Back in August 1987, Canada’s 78th Fraser Highlanders Pipe Band performed what would come to be known as a landmark concert in Ballymena, Co. Antrim – just a few days before they became the first ever non-Scottish band to win the Grade 1 title at that year’s World Pipe Band Championships.

Nearly three decades on, the recording of that concert, Live in Ireland ’87, remains one of the best selling pipe-band albums ever, with its innovative repertoire – including Don Thompson’s “Journey to Skye”, the first ever musical suite composed for pipe band – establishing it as a pivotal milestone in its field. For this special celebratory concert, a dozen members of that legendary 1987 line-up are joined by other household names of the piping world, including Chris Armstrong, Ryan Canning, Ian Duncan, Stuart Liddell, Steven McWhirter, Duncan Nicholson, Richard Parkes, Terry Tully and Ross Walker, while John Wilson and Bob Worrall will co-host the performance.’

IMG_2806Jenny was only about 12 first time round and has the mammoth task of learning the concert repertoire. She started tonight and trotted out a few tunes that will be in the concert. We look forward to hearing a lot more over the winter meetings.

The first round of the Scots Guards Association knock out competition takes place this coming Sunday 18th at 16.00hrs. Defending Champion Craig Sutherland v Brian Lamond. Should be cracker.Unknown

Our next meeting will be on Tuesday 27th where Lachie Dick and Jenny Hazzard will treat us to a bit Ceol Mor before heading off to the big London competition the following weekend.

Remember the Glenfiddich Championship a week Saturday 24th at Blair Castle.

Euan Anderson

Hon P/M


Filed under Uncategorized

Match Report Tuesday 29th September 2015

imagesSo where was the match report for Tuesday 15th September I hear you ask? Well truth be told, nobody could be arsed to do one.

Now this typically Scottish phrase ‘couldnae be arsed’ or ‘cannae be arsed’ or ‘ersed’ if you prefer, is disarmingly honest. After all how many times have we heard people come up with lame excuses for not showing up or failure to complete a task?

Did you go to band practice last night? Naw, couldnae be arsed.

Have you learned the set tunes yet? Naw, cannae be arsed. Usually followed by ‘loads of time’

How about popping along to the Eagle Pipers tonight? Naw, cannae be arsed.

Well we all feel like this from time to time about a multitude of things, but sometimes you just have to knuckle down. Can you imagine the school pupil turning up in the morning and when asked for their homework replying, ‘Sorry couldnae be arsed’

Thus, while refreshingly honest, the CBA attitude does have its consequences!

UnknownThe match report for the 15th was a victim to the CBA syndrome, which is disappointing, as apparently Kyle Howie, of Red Hot Chillie Pipers fame, turned up and put on a first class display of light music. Kyle attended the RSAMD and is currently a member of The MacKenzie Caledonian Pipe band.. The bagpipe is not the only instrument Kyle can play and he has written quite a few good compositions He is a great player with strong technique.

If you have Facebook have a look at this clip and you will see what I mean. It will probably also be on YouTube? Thunderstruck.

With the P/M away on a family holiday and others ‘resting’ it was a quiet night and the only other player of the evening was regular Gordon Hislop.

Tonight saw a healthier turn out and the P/M kicked the evening off with some 6/8s followed by some 3/4s. Suffering from a sore back and swollen left hand (all the result of a deep tissue massage from a wee chap called Pavil, who may or may not have a passport….) the P/M managed to waddle down the floor without falling over.

Iain Kirkland

Iain Kirkland

Next for shaving was Iain Kirkwood, who has been at the Eagles before but never played. It can be quite daunting to ‘break the ice’ but Iain was quickly into his stride and knocked off 2 x 2/4 marches The Crags of Stirling and The Argyllshire Gathering. Well done Iain.

Lachie Dick, who is now based in Glasgow and working around 70hrs per week as a junior doctor (pay the guys and girls what they deserve please) was not suffering from CBA. He was in fine form. Having settled the pipe down with some nice 9/8s he gave us an MSR kicking off with John MacDonald of Glencoe. With the pipe booming he played the hornpipe, GS Allan, followed by two jigs that were of the highest musical quality. It transpired the second jig was one of his own compositions that remains, as yet unnamed. Ahhem…….IMG_2751

The post pie piper, who has been suffering from acute CBA this year, made his first appearance of 2015. Andrew Allison was back and it has to be said in splendid nick. The pipe was quickly and accurately tuned and after a very nice MSR he played the Jigs Rory McLeod and Alexander MacAskill. Good hands.

IMG_2753The final payer of the night was Colin MacLellan. While Jenny and her mum Evelyn,(see below) who is over for a wee holiday, sat dreaming of 10K runs, Colin worked his way through his light music, starting off with a few waltzes. To finish off he produced a nice and positive rendition of The Groat that brought the evening to a very nice conclusion.

The next meeting is on Tuesday 13th October and remember to get your tickets for the Grants Championship that is on Saturday 24th October.IMG_2757

Euan Anderson

Hon P/M

Evelyn Hazzard

Evelyn Hazzard

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Match Report Tuesday 1st September 2015

IMG_2668 You can always tell when the Northern Meeting is due. Kaj Larsen and P/M Robert L. Kilgour take in an Eagles before their annual pilgrimage to Inverness. This year was no exception and it was great to see Bob in such fine form. In his 90’s now, one of Edinburgh’s elder statesmen is still as sharp as a tack and he has numerous facial expressions that will tell you just how the piper is doing. If the modern day piper is predisposed to take on some kitchen piping Bob will listen intently and then applaud only using his two pinkies. Classic.

Bob and Kai

Bob and Kaj

Inverness is now done and dusted and the Glenfiddich competitors have been determined. Congratulations to the big winners Calum Beaumont- Clasp, Findlay Johnstone – Gold Medal and Bruce Gandy winning his first Silver Star.

The Glenfiddich players are, in no particular order

Callum Beaumont

Bruce Gandy

Jack Lee

Stuart Liddell

Angus MacColl

Roddy MacLeod

John-Angus Smith

Iain Speirs

Finlay Johnston

Willie McCallum (28 in a row and 8 titles under his belt !!)

Date Saturday 24th October.

Nick Hudson

Nick Hudson

So back to our evening, a final chance to warm up for the Northern Meetings in front of an audience. ( why more pipers do not take this opportunity bemuses me ).

First for shaving was overseas guest Nick Hudson from Pittsburgh. USA, who was in tremendous form. He gave the pipe a quick tune and went into 2 x 2/4 marches Mrs Duncan MacFadyen and Invergordon’s Welcome to Queen Elizabeth II. He then played a few strathspeys and reels before giving a us some tough old jigs. Fingers were flying and Nick was in the form that has won him a few prizes round the games. He finished his spot with the ground and first variation of The Lament for Donald Dughall McKay. Fantastic.

Next up was Andrew Gary who is not as frequent an attendee as he used to be due to the fact he is playing with Fife

Andrew Gray

Andrew Gray

Constabulary who qualified for the G1 final for the first time..Andrew started with Major Manson’s Farewell to Clachantrushal and Alan Dodds Farewell to Scotland. After some strathspeys and reels he sat down to enjoy a couple of pies.



The post pie piper was Nils Michael who warmed up with some very musical 3/4 marches. He then went into some 2/4s starting off with an old Edinburgh City Police Pipe Band favourite, The Conundrum. Nils is a great stalwart of the Society and always ready to play a tune when asked.

The final player of the night,fresh from his second Captain John MacLellan Memorial recital dinner win, was Iain Speirs. Iain took full advantage of the floor going through most of his Inverness light music before playing a lovely Lament for the Children. Such was the calibre of the tune Andrew Gray dropped a pint. Unheard of.

Iain Speirs

Iain Speirs

And that was the evenings evening.

Due to the pressures of retirement- yes another holiday-The P/M will miss the next meeting which is on Tuesday 15th.

Scott Hannah World Champ Shotts and Dykehead 2015

Scott Hannah
World Champ Shotts and Dykehead 2015

Euan Anderson

Hon P/M

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Match Report Tuesday 11th August-Worlds week

Ed Neigh

Ed Neigh

Well by now you will know who has won what in Glasgow and with the band season coming to a close the focus moves towards the big solo contests at Oban and Inverness, not forgetting the Captain John MacLellan recital dinner on Saturday 29th August of course.457479_10152050602100453_260445037_o

We had our traditional visitors to the Eagles on the 11th, The Sons of Scotland Pipe Band. Bethany and the troops were on fine form. Worlds aside they had their sights set on a concert they were doing up at Balmoral Castle for the Queen. They do make the most of their trips here.

The only thing lacking on the night were pipes. Plenty of pipers who all thought they would have a wee rest!! So once the P/M had played a few tunes he handed his pipe to volunteer Keith McCallum from Ontario. Once he had played a couple of tunes up stepped Ronan Mummery IMG_2613from Melbourne who has just turned 15. He was the pre pie piper and played a set of tunes that came under the banner, The Reloaded Set.


Keith McCallum

Once the audience had loaded and reloaded pies we had a tune from Gordon Hislop. Once his pipe was settled he gave us the piobaireachd Grain in Hides and Corn in Sacks.

The origin of Grain In Hides And Corn In Sacks is unknown but there is a theory that the tune was composed to celebrate a good harvest. In this scenario the grain in hides refers to the effect of the grain ingested by cattle. The corn in sacks refers to the harvest itself. Another view suggests that it is a tune that grew out of the raiding into England. The Scots would carry a basic food

Ronan Mummary

Ronan Mummary

supply on their persons. Some grain would be in skins to protect it from the weather, some hardier food in sacks. The tune is noted in Angus MacKay’s manuscript as well as in the Campbell Canntaireachd. Neither MacKay or Campbell offer clues as to the composer or the inspiration for the tune.

Gordon Hislop

Gordon Hislop

The piece has been on the set gold medal tune list for some years now and as it was played by Gordon we paid tribute to the late great Ed Neigh from Canada, whose recent passing has made a huge dent in, not only Canadian circles,but around the piping globe. Rest easy Ed.

And that was the evenings evening.

There will be meetings on Tuesday the 18th August and Tuesday 1st September and fortnightly thereafter.

Ed Niegh

Ed Niegh

Euan Anderson

Hon Pipe Major

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized